Elden Ring cover art

Game review page • Tier I (Focused)

Elden Ring

FromSoftware's magnum opus: a harrowing open world where every horizon hides something worth dying for.

Tier I 97 Essential
Released
Feb 25, 2022
Developer
FromSoftware
Publisher
Bandai Namco Entertainment
Reviews
1 entry

Launch review

The review

FromSoftware's magnum opus: a harrowing open world where every horizon hides something worth dying for.

Tier I 97 Essential Launch review

Reviewed by CriticalPath Editorial

Published
Mar 10, 2022
Tested on
PC
Playtime
90+ hours
Read time
1 min read

The Lands Between Awaits

Elden Ring is the product of a remarkable collaboration between director Hidetaka Miyazaki and author George R.R. Martin, and it shows. The world of the Lands Between feels mythic in a way few game settings manage — not told to you through cutscenes or codec entries, but built into every ruined castle, every shattered covenant, every cryptic epitaph carved into ancient stone.

Open World, Open Possibilities

The transition from the tightly authored corridors of Dark Souls to a true open world is a triumph. Limgrave is large enough to feel genuinely expansive yet curated enough that every tree line hides a dungeon. Caelid rust-red blight, the crystalline majesty of Raya Lucaria, the vertiginous dread of the Mountaintops of the Giants each region carries a distinct visual grammar. Traversal by Torrent keeps the map feeling inviting rather than overwhelming.

Combat and Challenge

FromSoftware combat engine has never felt better. Every weapon archetype offers a genuinely distinct play style, and the generous number of build options means a second playthrough feels like a fundamentally different game.

The bosses are extraordinary. Margit, Godrick, Radahn, Rykard, Malenia these are encounters that demand study, pattern recognition, and precise execution. A handful in the late game tip from challenging into frustrating, but they are the exception. The rule is excellence.

Performance Note

The PC version shipped with notable frame-rate and stuttering issues. Multiple patches addressed the worst offenders, but at launch the technical state on PC fell short of the artistry on display.

Verdict

Elden Ring is one of the most significant releases of the decade: a work of genuine artistic ambition that also happens to be deeply, relentlessly fun. It earns every bit of its acclaim.

At a glance

Scorecard

What works

  • Breathtaking open-world design with unmatched density of secrets
  • Extraordinary boss encounters that test and genuinely reward mastery
  • Deep multi-path build system with real replay value
  • Rich layered lore delivered through environmental storytelling
  • Torrent traversal makes the vast map feel welcoming not daunting

What holds it back

  • PC launch suffered significant frame-rate and stuttering issues
  • Late-game pacing and area design dips vs mid-game peaks
  • Difficulty remains a meaningful barrier to entry for many players
  • Some legacy dungeon interiors feel repeated across the map

Methodology

Stat profile

Design 10/10

Excellent

Performance 7/10

Solid

Accessibility 5/10

Needs work

Content 10/10

Excellent

Audio/Visual 10/10

Excellent

Category average 8.4/10

Recommendation context

Who this is for

Best for: Players wanting a tier-leading action and rpg pick on PC.

Skip if: Skip if you do not enjoy action and rpg core loops.

Patch outlook: No patch-delay warning from the current verdict and tier comparison.

Tier context: Tier I (Focused) peers: #1/4, +2.5 vs tier average (94.5).

Expectation context: Expected: Exceeded. Result: Essential (97), rank 1/4 in Tier I.

This review does not currently flag a wait-for-patches warning.

Game profile

Where it fits

Platforms: PC, PS5, and Xbox Series

Genres: Action, RPG, and Open World

Review history

All review events from launch to latest, showing how the verdict changed over time.

  1. Tier I 97 Essential Launch review
    Read review →